Natural resources sit at the intersection of real assets and commodities. Land, trees, crops, and raw materials behave differently from stocks and bonds because their returns come from biology, weather, and physical scarcity rather than corporate earnings.
Raw land is undeveloped property held for future development or speculation. It produces no operating income. The only return source is price appreciation, typically driven by population growth, zoning changes, or proximity to expanding infrastructure.
- No cash yield. Property taxes, maintenance, and insurance create negative carry.
- Highly illiquid. Marketing periods of 6 to 24 months are common.
- Location-dependent. Returns are idiosyncratic, not market-wide.
- Optionality value. The right to develop later behaves like a call option on the local economy.
TRAP: Raw land is not a passive inflation hedge. Returns concentrate at the entitlement event (rezoning, annexation). Holding indefinitely without a catalyst earns negative real returns net of carrying costs.
Timberland is land planted with merchantable trees. It is one of the few asset classes with three independent return streams.
Common mistakes
- Assuming raw land hedges inflation passively. Without a development catalyst, holding costs erode returns. Trap: treating undeveloped land like farmland for inflation purposes.
- Conflating spot return with commodity ETF return. ETFs hold futures, not physicals. Persistent contango can cause an ETF to lose money even when spot is flat. Trap: "the oil ETF should match spot oil."
- Forgetting biological growth in timberland decomposition. Candidates often list "price" and "land" but omit growth. Trap: a question stating prices fell 5% and treating the entire return as negative.
Bottom line
- Raw land returns come from appreciation only; no income, and holding costs create negative carry absent a development catalyst
- Timberland returns = biological growth + timber price + land appreciation; trees grow regardless of market sentiment
- Farmland returns = crop income (rental or own-operate) + land appreciation; row crop vs. permanent crop split matters for flexibility and volatility
- Commodity returns = spot price change + roll yield + collateral yield; futures, not physicals, are the access vehicle
Exam shortcut
For commodities, always decompose into three pieces (spot, roll, collateral) and check the term structure first; sign of roll yield is half the question. For timberland, remember three return streams and the option to defer harvest. Map each natural resource to its primary diversification benefit: timber for market independence, farmland for inflation, commodities for inflation surprises, raw land for local optionality.
The full lesson (about 2,088 words, 14 min read) adds 2 worked examples, all 6 common mistakes, a self-check, free in the app.
Learning objectives
- natural resources
Browse all free CFA Level I lessons or jump into free CFA Level I practice questions.