An analyst's spouse inherits $3 million of stock in a company he covers. Nothing illegal has happened, and no client has been harmed. Standard VI still binds him, because it governs the appearance of bias, not just its realization.
Standard VI has three parts: VI(A) Avoid or Disclose Conflicts, VI(B) Priority of Transactions, and VI(C) Referral Fees. All three run on one engine. Where a personal or professional interest could reasonably be expected to impair independence and objectivity, you avoid it if you can and disclose it fully if you cannot.
A conflict of interest is any matter that could reasonably be expected to impair independence and objectivity or raise a question about whether judgment is free from bias. Conflicts arise among client interests, employer interests, and your own. A common source is compensation structure, especially incentive and bonus arrangements that reward immediate results with little regard for long-term value creation.
Best practice is avoidance of both actual conflicts and their appearance. When avoidance is unreasonable, disclose clearly and completely, mitigate the conflict where possible, and disclose how you mitigated it.
Common mistakes
- Treating disclosure as curative. Disclosure permits an unavoidable conflict; it never authorizes acting on a biased view, and avoidance remains the preferred answer.
- Boilerplate language. "Investment personnel are subject to policies regarding personal trading" fails the plain-language and effectiveness test.
- Penalizing family clients. Allocating an initial public offering (IPO) to a parent's fee-paying account last, after every other client, breaches duty to that client just as favoritism would.
Bottom line
- VI(A) Avoid or disclose: avoidance is best practice, disclosure is the fallback, and disclosures must be prominent, plain-language, and effective
- Always-disclose relationships: directorships, consultancies, underwriting and investment banking, market making, material beneficial ownership
- Beneficial ownership: direct or indirect pecuniary interest, power to vote, or power to dispose
- Update triggers: any material worsening of the conflict, such as bonuses shifting from annual to quarterly profits
Exam shortcut
Read the vignette for who benefits and when. If the benefit flows from a relationship or ownership, run VI(A): could this reasonably impair objectivity, was it avoidable, was it disclosed prominently? If the benefit comes from trade timing or allocation, run VI(B): did clients get their chance first?
The full lesson (about 1,950 words, 13 min read) adds 2 worked examples, all 6 common mistakes, a self-check, free in the app.
Learning objectives
- standard VI conflicts of interest
Browse all free CFA Level II lessons or jump into free CFA Level II practice questions.