A product manager prices a new SKU at $120 because manufacturing cost is $80 and the firm wants a 50% markup. Then a competitor launches at $95 with better features. Pricing fails when one approach answers a question that demanded three.
Every defensible price starts from one of three anchors.
- Market-based (comparables). Survey what competitors charge for the same or substitute products.
- Cost-based. Build the price up from unit cost by adding a markup or a target rate of return.
- Value-based. Quantify customer perceived value (productivity gains, switching costs avoided, brand prestige) and price as a share of that value.
DECISION: Commodity or price-taker context, use market-based. Differentiated product with measurable customer ROI, use value-based. Custom, regulated, or cost-advantaged context, use cost-based.
Cost-based pricing chooses a cost base (variable cost, full absorption cost, or full cost plus operating costs) and adds a markup. The cleanest version is cost plus target rate of return on invested capital.
Common mistakes
- Confusing target costing with cost-plus. Target costing starts from price (set by customer value) and subtracts target margin to get target cost. Cost-plus starts from cost and adds markup. The exam inverts the arrow.
- Using P = MC in every market structure. P = MC only holds in pure competition. In monopolistic competition, oligopoly, and monopoly, MR = MC sets quantity and P > MR, so price exceeds marginal cost.
- Treating inspection as value-added. Inspection exists because defects are possible. A perfect process needs none. Classify as nonvalue-added along with rework, scrap, and expediting.
Bottom line
- Three pricing approaches: market-based (competitor benchmark), cost-based (cost plus markup or target ROI), value-based (customer perceived value drives price).
- Target cost = target price − target operating income per unit. Value engineering closes any gap between current cost and target cost.
- Cost-plus target rate of return prices at ; it ignores demand and must be validated against market or value benchmarks.
- Short-term equilibrium price sets marginal revenue = marginal cost. In pure competition P = MR = MC; in monopoly P > MR = MC.
Exam shortcut
When the question gives target price and required margin and asks for allowable cost, compute target cost as price minus margin per unit. Then compare to current cost; the gap is the value-engineering target. When the question names a market structure and asks for the profit-maximizing rule, the answer is MR = MC in every structure.
The full lesson (about 2,904 words, 19 min read) adds 2 worked examples, all 6 common mistakes, a self-check, free in the app.
Learning objectives
- 2C3
Browse all free CMA Part 2 lessons or jump into free CMA Part 2 practice questions.