To identify factors controlling a preparation engagement, the accountant first considers the requested service, applicable scope, and intended financial reporting framework.
A preparation engagement uses management's information to produce financial statements under a specified framework without providing assurance. It is a nonattest service that ordinarily produces no accountant's report, audit opinion, or negative-assurance review conclusion.
Under the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) professional-conduct framework, a compilation is an attest service despite providing no assurance. That classification does not make it an attestation engagement governed by the Statements on Standards for Attestation Engagements (SSAE).
The accountant evaluates the substance of the agreement rather than inferring an engagement solely from software output, statement formatting, or the recipient's identity.
- Separately engaging an accountant to prepare financial statements generally brings the preparation provisions into consideration, including when another accountant will subsequently audit those statements.
- Preparation performed as part of the same accountant's audit, review, or compilation of those statements follows that engagement's applicable requirements.
Common mistakes
- Unsigned terms. A detailed engagement letter signed only by the accountant leaves the required agreement incompletely executed.
- First page only. A legend on page 1 does not satisfy normal delivery when pages 2 through 5 lack it.
- Unaudited label alone. That label leaves open whether limited assurance was provided through a review.
Bottom line
- The agreed service and applicable scope determine whether preparation provisions apply; formatting statements or sending them to a lender does not automatically establish compilation.
- Preparation is a nonattest service providing no assurance and ordinarily producing statements without an accountant's report.
- Signed written terms identify the framework, responsibilities, limitations, and no-assurance communication; management retains responsibility for the information, judgments, adjustments, and statements.
- Independence need not be determined or its absence disclosed for preparation itself, while separate engagements retain their own independence requirements.
Exam shortcut
The engagement agreement distinguishes preparation from bookkeeping assistance and preparation within another service; the recipient alone does not determine the service. Delivery questions turn on page coverage. Unavailable legends permit an acceptable separate disclaimer; those alternatives presuppose sufficient information and an acceptable presentation. Refusal to supply information needed to complete preparation requires withdrawal and communication of the reasons.
The full lesson (about 3,556 words, 24 min read) adds 2 worked examples, all 6 common mistakes, a self-check, free in the app.
Learning objectives
- IV.C1
Browse all free CPA AUD lessons or jump into free CPA AUD practice questions.