AICPA Representative Tasks (verbatim). 1. Application: Calculate the realized gain, recognized gain and deferred gain on like-kind property exchange and involuntary conversion transactions for tax purposes and the basis of the asset received as a result of the transactions. 2. Analysis: Review asset sale and exchange transactions, and relevant supporting documentation, to determine whether they are taxable or nontaxable.
Every property disposition involves three distinct gain calculations that determine current tax liability and future basis.
KEY: Nontaxable dispositions do not eliminate gain, they defer it. The deferred gain reduces the basis of replacement property, ensuring eventual recognition upon subsequent disposition.
Section 1031 permits tax-deferred exchanges of qualifying real property held for productive use in a trade or business or for investment. After the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (2017), like-kind treatment applies exclusively to real property; personal property exchanges are fully taxable.
Common mistakes
- Applying §1031 to personal property exchanges. After 2017, like-kind exchange treatment applies only to real property. Trap: "exchange my equipment for similar equipment tax-free." Correct: personal property exchanges are fully taxable.
- Forgetting debt relief is boot. When the taxpayer's mortgage is assumed by the other party without offsetting debt assumption, the debt relief constitutes boot. Trap: "no cash changed hands, so no boot." Correct: net debt relief triggers gain recognition.
- Confusing mandatory versus elective deferral. Section 1031 deferral is mandatory when requirements are satisfied; §1033 deferral is elective. Trap: "taxpayer elected not to defer the §1031 gain." Correct: §1031 deferral cannot be waived.
Bottom line
- Like-kind exchanges under §1031 apply only to real property held for business or investment; personal property exchanges became fully taxable after 2017
- Realized gain equals amount realized minus adjusted basis; recognized gain equals the lesser of realized gain or boot received
- Boot includes cash, personal property, and net debt relief; debt assumed offsets debt relieved
- Deferred gain equals realized gain minus recognized gain and reduces the basis of replacement property
Exam shortcut
"Boot equals cash plus net debt relief." When calculating recognized gain, add cash received to the excess of liabilities shed over liabilities assumed. If you assume more than you shed, net mortgage boot is zero (you cannot have negative boot). "Deferred gain = basis reduction." The deferred gain always equals the difference between the replacement property's FMV and its adjusted basis.
The full lesson (about 4,466 words, 30 min read) adds 10 worked examples, all 6 common mistakes, a self-check, free in the app.
Learning objectives
- IV.A1
Browse all free CPA TCP lessons or jump into free CPA TCP practice questions.