Sample Questions
Relevering estimates a firm's leveraged (equity) beta from its unleveraged (asset) beta:
where is the leveraged beta, is the unleveraged beta, is the marginal tax rate, and is the debt-to-equity ratio. To estimate a subject company's beta, first unlever the beta of a comparable company with similar business risk, then relever it using the subject company's tax rate and debt-to-equity ratio.
Bastion's ESG composite score of 51 is below the mandate's minimum of 60, so Bastion is ineligible whatever its valuation; Solara's score of 74 meets the minimum. The 15% limit caps the combined weight of holdings classified as carbon-intensive but does not by itself require excluding any holding, so the exclusion rests on the score minimum.
The WACC difference is , or 260 bp, and the EV/EBITDA gap is . The head of responsible investing argues that the higher WACC only partially compensates for ESG-related risk. ESG integration can reflect material environmental and governance risks in forecast cash flows, valuation multiples, or discount rates, but a lower multiple and faster historical growth do not show that the remaining risk is compensated, and no valuation factor overrides an explicit eligibility rule.
Bastion's emissions intensity points to transition risk, such as tighter regulation and stranded assets, which scenario analysis could help quantify. Its board metrics and fine history warrant governance scrutiny. These analyses could inform the valuation or sizing of an eligible holding, but they are not needed here because the score minimum already settles eligibility.